A property owner's exposure to a contractor's workplace injury may turn on the contractual arrangements that brought the contractor onto the property, even when the owner did not hire the contractor directly. In Schurman Family Company TIC v. Superior Court, No. A174194, the First District Court of Appeal held that a commercial landlord fell within the chain of delegation protected by the Privette doctrine after its tenant hired an independent contractor to perform work contemplated by the lease.

The decision rejects a categorical distinction between hiring tenants and non-hiring landlords. It also sharpens an existing disagreement among California appellate courts over whether Privette protection requires a hiring relationship at every stage of the contractual chain. For property owners and their insurers, the opinion provides a significant defense where a lease authorizes work that the tenant then entrusts to an independent contractor. Its reach, however, remains tied to that relationship and subject to the doctrine's recognized exceptions.

The Lease and the Rooftop Injury

Schurman owned an Oakland warehouse and leased portions of the roof and interior to Verizon for the installation, operation, and maintenance of communications equipment. The lease granted Verizon access through the building and across the rooftop to service its facilities. Schurman retained responsibility for structural maintenance, while Verizon assumed responsibility for the nonstructural portion of the leased premises. Verizon hired L.D. Strobel as the general contractor for its cell site installation project. The construction agreement assigned Strobel control over its workers. responsibility for their health and safety, and authority over the means and methods of construction.

Strobel employee Phuokhao Bounxaysana was working on ground floor equipment when a Verizon technician asked him and a coworker to check radio serial numbers in a rooftop enclosure. The enclosure's access door was secured with screws. Without a screwdriver, Bounxaysana left the steel walkway to look for another way inside. He stepped onto a sloped roof section, fell through a skylight, and suffered serious injuries. It is important to note, the skylight was outside the portion of the roof leased to Verizon.

Bounxaysana sued both Verizon and Schurman for negligence and premises liability. The trial court granted Verizon summary judgment under Privette but denied Schurman's motion because Shurman had not hired the contractor. Verizon's judgment was not appealed, leaving its entitlement to Privette protection established for purpose of the writ proceeding.

Delegation as the Basis for Protection

Under Privette v. Superior Court (1993) 5 Cal.4th 689, a party hiring an independent contractor is generally not liable for injuries sustained by the contractor's employees in performing the work. Although the doctrine originated in concerns about workers' compensation and the inequity of imposing greater liability on a nonnegligent hirer than on the injured worker's employer, subsequent decisions have placed delegation of workplace safety at the center of the analysis.

The Supreme Court's early decisions broadened that protection beyond the original peculiar risk claim. In Toland v. Sunland Housing Group, Inc. (1998) 18 Cal.4th 253, 256-57, the court held that the doctrine also barred peculiar risk liability based on a hirer's failure to require special precautions for inherently dangerous work. In Camargo v. Tjarrda Dairy (2001) 25 Cal.4th 1235, it extended the same reasoning to negligent hiring claims brought by a contractor's employee. Those decisions reflected a consistent concern about imposing greater liability on the hirer than on the contractor responsible for the work.

An independent contractor ordinarily controls how its work is performed and assumes the corresponding responsibility to perform it safely. The hiring relationship therefore creates a presumptive delegation of workplace safety duties. SeaBright Ins. Co. v. US Airways, Inc. (2011) 52 Cal.4th 590, 594, 597-600. That delegation can operate through multiple contractual relationships. In Tverberg v. Fillner Construction, Inc. (2010) 49 Cal.4th 518, 528-529, the Supreme Court explained that protection extends through a chain of delegation when responsibility for the work passes indirectly to an independent contractor.

In the case at hand, Schurman argued that its lease placed it within that chain. Bounxaysana maintained that the absence of a hiring relationship between Schurman and either Verizon or Strobel defeated this defense. The appellate court agreed with Schurman. Once Verizon hired Strobel and delegated responsibility for workplace safety, the court found no basis for requiring a separate hiring relationship at every preceding link. The lease supplied the necessary connection. It authorized the communications work, provided access for its performance, and resulted in Verizon hiring Strobel to undertake that work. Schurman's involvement was therefore connected to the contractor's assignment through the lease itself.

The court also found this result served the doctrine's underlying fairness principles. Schurman had no control over Bounxaysana's work. Imposing liability on the landlord after the hiring tenant was relieved of liability would create the disparity that Privette and its progeny sought to avoid. The contractual delegation of safety responsibility and the policy against disproportionate liability thus supported the same conclusion.

A Direct Disagreement with Ramirez

The trial court relied on Ramirez v. PK I Plaza 580 SC LP (2022) 85 Cal.App.5th 252, which involved an independent contractor hired by a shopping center tenant to remove an exterior sign. After the contractor fell through a roof opening, the Ramirez majority concluded that the owner could not invoke Privette because it had not hired him. Schurman expressly declined to follow the Ramirez majority's hiring requirement. The court explained that the Supreme Court had not decided whether a non-hiring lessor could receive Privette protection. References to hirers in decisions arising from hiring relationships therefore did not establish that every participant in the chain must directly hire another participant.

The court also relied on appellate decisions extending protection beyond direct hirers, including Lopez v. University Partners (1997) 54 Cal.App.4th 1117, which protected a landowner and its hiring tenant, and Collins v. Diamond Generating Corp. (2024) 107 Cal.App.5th 1162, which recognized that an indirect owner could fall within the chain of delegation. It further cited Andrews v. Wagner (2025) 116 Cal.App.5th 766, involving a homeowner whose insurer hired the contractor. The result is an express conflict over the significance of a landlord's non-hiring status. Schurman adds substantial support for examining the full contractual relationship, but it does not eliminate the contrary authority.

The circumstances of those decisions illustrate the range of relationships through which delegation may occur. In Lopez, a university leased property to a tenant that hired a contractor whose employee was injured in a trench collapse. The court protected both the university and the tenant. In Collins, the court reversed a judgment arising from a fatal power plant explosion because the jury was not instructed on Privette and its exceptions. Although the indirect owner's liability remained for determination on remand, the absence of direct hiring relationship did not justify withholding the defense. Lopez, supra 54 Cal.App.4th at 1120-25; Collins, supra, 107 Cal.App.5th at 1166-1167.

In Andrews, the homeowner's insurer arranged the inspection that brought the injured contractor's employee onto the property. The court concluded that the homeowner's insurance payments and consent to the inspection supported delegation of workplace safety despite the insurer's role in hiring the contractor. Schurman viewed that reasoning as further support or looking beyond the identity of the immediate hirer. Andrews, supra, 116 Cal.App.5th at p. 769, 773.

The court also drew support from Ruiz v. Herman Weissker, Inc. (2005) 130 Cal.App.4th 52, 55-56. There a contract administrator received Privette protection even though it neither hired nor paid the contractor and had no contractual relationship with it. Ruiz treated those distinctions as legally insignificant where the injury arose from work for which the independent contractor bore primary responsibility. The result of this precedent is an express conflict over the significance of the landlord's non-hiring status. Schurman adds substantial support for examining the full contractual relationship, but it does not eliminate contrary authority.

The court also distinguished decisions in which the connection for delegation was missing. In Gordon v. ARC Manufacturing, Inc. (2019) 43 Cal.App.5th 705, a prospective purchaser hired a roofer to inspect a building before buying it. The roofer fell through a camouflaged opening. The seller had neither assigned the inspection work nor hired the contractor, leaving no comparable chain of delegation between the owner and the injured roofer. Likewise, in Zuniga v. Cherry Avenue Auction, Inc. (2021) 61 Cal.App.5th 980 involved vendors injured while setting up a booth at an outdoor swap meet. No independent contractor had been hired. Therefore, there was no initial delegation of workplace safety to trigger Privette protection.

These distinctions give the holding boundaries. Ownership alone does not establish the defense, and a visitor's status as a contractor does not automatically place the owner within a protected chain. Schurman tied its conclusion to a lease expressly contemplating contractor work and a tenant's subsequent hiring of a contractor to perform the work.

The Hazard and the Unasserted Exceptions

The contractor's knowledge of the skylights also mattered. Strobel's awareness was undisputed, although the parties disagreed about whether Bounxaysana himself knew of the hazard. The court identified the contractor's knowledge as the relevant inquiry. Under Gonzalez v. Mathis (2021) 12 Cal.5th 29, 45, 50, knowledge of a premises hazard generally leaves the contractor responsible for deciding whether and how the work can be performed safely.

Gonzalez makes that responsibility substantial. Delegation generally continues even when the contractor cannot readily eliminate the known hazard or adopt reasonable precautions to avoid it. Once informed of the condition, the contractor has the information needed to assess whether the assignment can safely proceed. Responsibility for workplace safety is not extended or renewed because the condition is difficult to address.

The court reached its result despite Schurman's structural maintenance obligations and the skylight's location outside Verizon's leased rooftop space. Those facts did not defeat the delegation defense on the issues presented, however, and should not be read as establishing that maintenance obligations or the location of an accident can never affect the analysis. Privette remains subject to recognized exceptions. Under Hooker v. Department of Transportation (2002) 27 Cal.App.4th 198, 202, liability may arise where a hirer's exercise of retained control affirmatively contributes to the injury. Under Kinsmen v. Unocal Corp. (2005) 37 Cal.4th 659, 664, a landowner may be liable for failing to warn of a concealed, preexisting hazard that the contractor neither knew about nor could have reasonably discovered.

The retained control exception requires attention to how control was exercised. Hooker distinguished a general failure to prevent unsafe contractor practices from conduct that affirmatively contributes to an injury. Its companion decision, McKown v. Wal-Mart Stores, Inc. (2002) 27 Cal.4th 219, similarly recognized liability where a hirer furnished unsafe equipment that affirmatively contributed to the worker's injury. These decisions preserve liability for the hirer's own conduct within the delegation framework.

Bounxaysana did not assert either exception in opposing Schurman's motion. The court therefore did not decide their application. Its ruling addresses whether Schurman could invoke Privette, rather than whether particular conduct by a landlord might overcome the defense.

Implications for Property Owners and Defense Counsel

Schurman makes the lease and related construction agreements central to the defense of contractor injury claims against commercial landlords. The relevant evidence extends beyond identifying who signed the contractor's agreement. It includes the work contemplated by the lease, the tenant's access rights, the contractor's responsibility for the work, and its knowledge of the alleged hazard.

For defense counsel, those documents can establish how responsibility for workplace safety reached the injured worker's employer. The opinion also reinforces the importance of addressing any asserted exception separately. A contractual chain may support Privette protection while evidence of affirmative interference or an undisclosed concealed hazard presents a different question.

The Court of Appeal directed the trial court to vacate its denial of Schurman's motion and enter summary judgment for the landlord. The decision's central contribution is its recognition that a lease can place a non-hiring owner within the chain of delegation when the tenant engages a contractor to perform the contemplated work. In that setting, the absence of a direct hiring relationship does not, by itself, foreclose the defense.

Logo Cookie Preference Center

Your Privacy

When you visit our website, we use cookies on your browser to collect information. The information collected might relate to you, your preferences, or your device, and is mostly used to make the site work as you expect it to and to provide a more personalized web experience. For more information about how we use Cookies, please see our Privacy Policy.

Strictly Necessary Cookies

Always Active

Necessary cookies enable core functionality such as security, network management, and accessibility. These cookies may only be disabled by changing your browser settings, but this may affect how the website functions.

Functional Cookies

Always Active

Some functions of the site require remembering user choices, for example your cookie preference, or keyword search highlighting. These do not store any personal information.

Form Submissions

Always Active

When submitting your data, for example on a contact form or event registration, a cookie might be used to monitor the state of your submission across pages.

Performance Cookies

Performance cookies help us improve our website by collecting and reporting information on its usage. We access and process information from these cookies at an aggregate level.

Powered by Firmseek